PBV Utility Allowance: Tenant-Paid Utilities and Reimbursements
A PBV utility allowance is not a payment of your actual electric, gas, water, or other utility bills. It is an amount determined under the public housing agency’s utility allowance schedule for qualifying utilities and services that the tenant is responsible for paying. The allowance becomes part of the Project-Based Voucher rent calculation, and if it is greater than the household’s Total Tenant Payment, the difference may become a utility reimbursement.
The amount is local. A family in one PBV property should not assume that a utility allowance shown by another housing authority, another city, or even a different type of unit will apply to its apartment. The PHA administering the Project-Based Voucher program must use the applicable utility allowance schedule and the utility responsibilities for the specific assisted unit.
Which utilities are included depends on who is responsible for paying them
The first question is not how large the utility bill is. It is which utilities the tenant is required to pay under the assisted tenancy.
A utility allowance can apply to qualifying tenant-paid utilities and housing services. Depending on the unit and local schedule, those may include expenses such as space heating, air conditioning, cooking, water heating, water, sewer, trash collection, and other electric service. HUD rules also address allowances for a tenant-supplied refrigerator or range when applicable.
If the owner pays for a particular utility as part of the rent, that utility is not treated as a tenant-paid utility for purposes of the family’s allowance. A tenant therefore cannot simply add every household utility expense together and treat the total as the PBV utility allowance.
Nonessential personal services are different. A utility allowance is not intended to cover expenses such as cable or satellite television simply because the household pays those bills.
The PHA uses a local utility allowance schedule
The PHA must maintain a utility allowance schedule for tenant-paid utilities and other covered housing services. The schedule is based on the typical cost of utilities for energy-conservative households occupying housing of similar size and type in the same locality, using normal community consumption patterns and current utility rates.
That is why there is no single national PBV utility allowance. The applicable amount can depend on details such as:
- which utilities the tenant pays;
- the type of utility or fuel used;
- the number of bedrooms used for the applicable allowance;
- the type of housing, such as an apartment, townhouse, or detached unit;
- local utility rates; and
- the PHA utility allowance schedule currently in effect.
Under current PBV rules, the PHA’s applicable area-wide utility allowance schedule generally applies to PBV units as well as tenant-based voucher units. HUD regulations also recognize energy-efficient utility allowance schedules in qualifying circumstances. A project-specific allowance should not be assumed merely because a property is project-based.
The utility allowance is an estimate, not your actual monthly bill
This distinction matters whenever a tenant compares a rent notice with a utility bill. The allowance is based on scheduled estimates of reasonable utility consumption and applicable rates. It is not calculated by taking the family’s actual bill each month and subtracting that exact amount from the rent.
Your real bill can be higher or lower than the utility allowance. Weather, thermostat settings, household usage, appliance efficiency, utility rates, and other factors can change actual consumption. Those differences do not automatically change the allowance for that month.
For example, a high electric bill does not by itself prove that the PHA used the wrong utility allowance. The first thing to compare is the allowance actually applied to the household with the PHA’s current schedule for the relevant unit and tenant-paid utilities.
The same principle works in the other direction. If the household’s actual utility bill is lower than the scheduled allowance, that does not automatically reduce the allowance to the amount printed on the bill.
Utility allowance affects both gross rent and the family’s rent to the owner
The utility allowance has a specific place in PBV rent terminology. Gross rent includes the rent to owner plus the applicable utility allowance. When the family is responsible for covered utilities, the allowance recognizes that part of the housing cost even though the money is not being paid to the property owner as rent.
The family’s tenant rent to the owner is generally determined by subtracting the applicable utility allowance from Total Tenant Payment. That is why a household can have one figure for Total Tenant Payment and a different figure for the amount actually paid to the property owner.
The distinction between utility allowance, gross rent, tenant rent, rent to owner, and the PHA’s housing assistance payment is explained more fully in the PBV payment standard and rent-to-owner guide.
For utility purposes, the important point is simpler: the allowance recognizes qualifying utilities the family must pay separately instead of treating those costs as though they were included in the owner’s rent.
When a utility allowance can result in a reimbursement
A utility reimbursement can occur when the applicable utility allowance is greater than the family’s Total Tenant Payment.
In that situation, the family’s tenant rent to the owner is zero, and the excess of the utility allowance over Total Tenant Payment is the utility reimbursement. The reimbursement is not an extra benefit added simply because the tenant pays utilities. It results only when the applicable allowance exceeds the household’s Total Tenant Payment.
The PHA must describe in its Administrative Plan whether utility reimbursements are paid directly to the family or directly to the utility supplier. If the PHA pays the utility supplier directly, the family must be notified of the amount paid.
This also means two households in similar PBV units can have the same utility allowance without receiving the same reimbursement. One household may receive a reimbursement while another does not because Total Tenant Payment is household-specific.
A utility reimbursement is not reimbursement of the actual utility bill
The word “reimbursement” can cause confusion. In this context, the PHA is not normally asking the household to submit its monthly utility bill and then paying back the exact amount spent.
The reimbursement is based on the relationship between two program figures: the applicable utility allowance and Total Tenant Payment. If the allowance exceeds Total Tenant Payment, the excess is the reimbursement.
A tenant therefore should not assume that a $200 electric bill creates a $200 utility reimbursement. Nor should a household assume that paying several utilities automatically means a reimbursement is due.
The utility responsibility must first be covered by the applicable PHA schedule, and the allowance must then exceed Total Tenant Payment before an excess exists.
Unit type and utility responsibility can change the applicable amount
A PHA utility schedule is not simply one dollar amount for every apartment. HUD rules require the schedule to account for relevant housing characteristics and utility categories.
An apartment using tenant-paid electric heat may not have the same allowance as a similar unit where the owner supplies heat. A townhouse may fall under a different housing-type category from a high-rise apartment. Fuel type can also matter when the schedule distinguishes among electricity, natural gas, oil, or other locally used sources.
The applicable bedroom size also matters. Under the utility allowance rules, the PHA generally uses the appropriate allowance for the lesser of the dwelling-unit size actually leased or the family unit size determined under the PHA’s subsidy standards, subject to the reasonable-accommodation rule for certain larger units.
Those details are why a tenant should compare the rent determination with the actual PHA schedule rather than a utility allowance found through a general internet search.
The PHA must review its utility allowance schedule every year
Utility rates do not stay fixed, so HUD requires the PHA to review its utility allowance schedule annually. The PHA must revise the allowance for a utility category when the utility rate has changed by 10 percent or more since that category was last revised.
The PHA also must maintain information supporting its review and revisions. HUD can direct a PHA to correct errors or otherwise update the schedule when necessary.
A schedule revision does not mean the family’s actual utility bill changed by the same percentage. The schedule and the household’s real bill remain separate. What changes is the program allowance used by the PHA when the revised amount becomes applicable to the household’s rent determination.
Check the utility responsibility before questioning the dollar amount
If the utility allowance on a PBV rent notice looks wrong, start with the utility responsibilities for the unit. Determine whether the tenant or owner is responsible for heat, cooking fuel, electricity, water, sewer, trash, and any other utility category involved.
Then check the current PHA utility allowance schedule and make sure the allowance corresponds to the applicable unit characteristics and utilities. Useful items to compare include:
- the current PHA utility allowance schedule;
- the bedroom size used for the allowance;
- the housing or building type;
- the fuel or energy source;
- which utilities the lease assigns to the tenant;
- the utility allowance shown on the current rent determination; and
- any utility reimbursement shown by the PHA.
If the lease says the owner pays a utility but the rent determination treats it as tenant-paid, or the tenant is being charged for a utility that the documents assign to the owner, that mismatch should be raised with the PHA or property management. The issue is the assigned utility responsibility and the applicable schedule, not simply whether the tenant thinks the bill is high.
What to remember when your utility costs change
An increase in the household’s actual utility bill does not automatically create a larger PBV utility allowance. The PHA establishes and updates the applicable schedule under HUD rules rather than recalculating the allowance from each family’s monthly bills.
Likewise, receiving a utility allowance does not guarantee a utility reimbursement. A reimbursement exists only when the applicable allowance exceeds Total Tenant Payment.
Keep the current rent notice and, when available, the PHA utility allowance schedule used for the unit. Those two records make it much easier to determine whether a change came from the utility schedule, the household’s rent calculation, or a change in who is responsible for paying a utility.